Sign Vick as Back-up

[Thurmanation]

He's far better then Fitz, and he can also compete with Carson. I don't care what anyone says Vick is a playmaker. He took his team to the NFC championship on his own.

[kingwilly]

It fits SoP's role as "Redeemer of Men" to a T.

I'd laugh this off but it is an interesting idea, the merits and perils of which serve as a needed distraction from the cold reality that this is currently a very bad football team in every facet of the game.

[Spor_tees]

It fits SoP's role as "Redeemer of Men" to a T.

I'd laugh this off but it is an interesting idea, the merits and perils of which serve as a needed distraction from the cold reality that this is currently a very bad football team in every facet of the game.

Shoot bring him in as a backup QB slash RB. The guy is better than almost any other RB the Bengals have on the roster right now. If anyone is afraid he might not be in playing shape, Marvin can go buy some dobermans and have them chase Vick around for the first half of training camp...he'll get in shape pretty fast!

[Pidge]

Goodell would go spastic. He'd probably just nuke Cincy.

Plus a QB with zero accuracy is about as useful as a tits on a bull.

[gregstephens]

Goodell would go spastic. He'd probably just nuke Cincy.

Plus a QB with zero accuracy is about as useful as a tits on a bull.

After the latest episode of 'As the Pacman Turns', I'm not sure Goodell has any room to talk anymore. Talking about losing credibility.

[HoosierCat]

Goodell would go spastic. He'd probably just nuke Cincy.

So what you're saying is that there's no real downside...

[Thurmanation]

Goodell would go spastic. He'd probably just nuke Cincy.

Plus a QB with zero accuracy is about as useful as a tits on a bull.

I don't know why people say Vick is inaccurate. He's got a better rating then most the starting QB's in the league. The problem with Vick was they were the Atlanta Vick's, No O-line, No WR, just Vick and Crumpler. I could gaurentee if you put Vick on the Pats or Colts they'll win the Super Bowl every year.

I'm not looking forward to playing against possibly Vick and the Bucs or Vick and the Vikings.

[BengalPimp]

Plus a QB with zero accuracy is about as useful as a tits on a bull.

[TJJackson]

Why don't we just bring back Odell Thurman instead, eh Thurmanat....err.....JungleD?

When is Rae Carruth getting out? We could use him too, right?

What about that safety from the Chargers who was caught dealing/transporting drugs? He's available, right?

[BengalPimp]

Why don't we just bring back Odell Thurman instead, eh Thurmanat....err.....JungleD?

When is Rae Carruth getting out? We could use him too, right?

What about that safety from the Chargers who was caught dealing/transporting drugs? He's available, right?

Can't you see the transitions? From Thurmanation...to Jungle D...to The Vick-Pound.....

[COB]

Goodell would go spastic. He'd probably just nuke Cincy.

So what you're saying is that there's no real downside...

[Jet23]

He's far better then Fitz, and he can also compete with Carson. I don't care what anyone says Vick is a playmaker. He took his team to the NFC championship on his own.

I would have a hard time explaining that to Major..............my dog.

[membengal]

Worst f**kin' idea I have ever seen forwarded on this forum. And that's saying something.

[HairOnFire]

Worst f**kin' idea I have ever seen forwarded on this forum. And that's saying something.

Which idea? Signing Vick OR nuking Cincy?

[HoosierCat]

Worst f**kin' idea I have ever seen forwarded on this forum. And that's saying something.

Which idea? Signing Vick OR nuking Cincy?

I think there's a compromise here: how about nuking Vick?

[membengal]

Both. There are the occasional redeeming qualities to Cincy. It shouldn't be nuked.

[HairOnFire]

Both. There are the occasional redeeming qualities to Cincy. It shouldn't be nuked.

So convential high-explosives it is then.

[Jet23]

Both. There are the occasional redeeming qualities to Cincy. It shouldn't be nuked.

So convential high-explosives it is then.

As long as you keep it within I-275.........Daisy Cutters it is!

[cincy9275]

well hell lets just go ahead and sign clarrett also, give me a f**king break. that's all this team needs is more punks and thugs. to go along with the babies and pu**ies we have now!

[membengal]

Both. There are the occasional redeeming qualities to Cincy. It shouldn't be nuked.

So convential high-explosives it is then.

Yup, those would be fine.

[Thurmanation]

Ok, It was just an idea. Although it will be fun watching Vick win a Superbowl with another team.

Yes TJ.. I said Superbowl.

[Pidge]

Goodell would go spastic. He'd probably just nuke Cincy.

Plus a QB with zero accuracy is about as useful as a tits on a bull.

I don't know why people say Vick is inaccurate. He's got a better rating then most the starting QB's in the league. The problem with Vick was they were the Atlanta Vick's, No O-line, No WR, just Vick and Crumpler. I could gaurentee if you put Vick on the Pats or Colts they'll win the Super Bowl every year.

I'm not looking forward to playing against possibly Vick and the Bucs or Vick and the Vikings.

He has a big arm. His running ability has meant that he's never needed to really get his accuracy down. Accuracy is a necessity for most QBs. He, however, can just tuck it and run if he doesn't have a wide open receiver. You gain a little, lose a little I guess.

No doubt his team wasn't the greatest but all that does is reaffirm his decision to run rather try and QB a team. Reinforces bad habits, imo.

This doesn't even mention the fact that he's shown such poor poor judgement. With this team's recent history, it would be better if he sought redemption somewhere else.

[kentjett]

Sign him and use him like reggie bush.

[Ickey44]

Goodell would go spastic. He'd probably just nuke Cincy.

Plus a QB with zero accuracy is about as useful as a tits on a bull.

I don't know why people say Vick is inaccurate. He's got a better rating then most the starting QB's in the league. The problem with Vick was they were the Atlanta Vick's, No O-line, No WR, just Vick and Crumpler. I could gaurentee if you put Vick on the Pats or Colts they'll win the Super Bowl every year.

I'm not looking forward to playing against possibly Vick and the Bucs or Vick and the Vikings.

Matt Ryan is having a near Pro-Bowl year with those receivers you say can't catch. Vick made things happen with his legs. He can't read a defense and while he has a cannon of an arm, his accuracy did (and prolly still does) suck.

[kneepit]

Vick would be awesome with the Bengals. They could get him 12-15 touches a game in the wildcat offense or just line him up as a running back.

I know he abused dogs and I'm not defending that but he paid his price to society. Many players have participated in cock fighting and nobody cares. It is legal in some states. If the response to that is "It is legal, there", then ask yourself if this is a crime issue or a animal issue. If this is a crime issue, he paid his debt...move on. If it is an animal issue, we could find many others to beat up.