With all the non-playoff spots set, here's a roundup of post-week 18 mocks:
McShay:
10. Edge Rueben Bain Jr., Miami
Bain’s production dipped for a few games in the middle of the year, but watching him over the past month (especially in the first two rounds of the CFP) has reminded NFL teams of how impactful this dude could be at the next level. Yes, he has short arms. And yes, some scouts have mentioned a 3-technique role as an option in the NFL. But there aren’t many more disruptive and impactful defensive players in the country. His 8.5 sacks this season ranks tied for 23rd in the FBS, so we’re not talking about marginal sack production. Furthermore, he ranks third (minimum 100 pass-rush snaps) among P4 edge rushers with a 23.7 pass-rush win rate.
https://mcshay-report.beehiiv.com/p/mock-draft-1-0-let-the-great-qb-debate-begin
Baumgardner:
10. Cincinnati Bengals: Peter Woods, DT, Clemson
Woods’ body of work is still impressive enough to discuss him this high up the board, although I’d understand if some are nervous about him after his rather average 2025 campaign. When he’s right, though, Woods has athletic ability worthy of top-five consideration.
https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/6939289/2026/01/05/nfl-mock-draft-2026-fernando-mendoza-dante-moore/
Renner:
10. Caleb Downs, S, Ohio State
Caleb Downs is the reliable secondary player the Bengals desperately need. He's not only assignment-sure in coverage but also rarely misses tackles.
https://www.cbssports.com/nfl/draft/news/renner-2026-nfl-mock-draft-top-18-pics-set-trades-expected-weak-class/
USA Today:
10. Caleb Downs, S, Ohio State
A two-time unanimous All-American and Thorpe Award winner, Downs accomplished nearly everything imaginable for a collegiate defensive back. While some franchises might be reticent to take a safety in the top 10, the do-everything defender shouldn't be reduced to his positional label.
https://www.usatoday.com/story/sports/nfl/draft/2026/01/04/nfl-mock-draft-2026-first-round-order-projection/88006263007/
TDN:
10. Spencer Fano, OT, Utah
The Cincinnati Bengals once again had a lost season due to Joe Burrow being injured, which was followed up by some interesting comments from Burrow. I think the front office should take what Burrow had to say seriously and look to continue to invest in key positions or risk losing their quarterback. With the front office feeling the pressure, they decide to draft OT Spencer Fano. Fano is an athletic offensive lineman who thrives in pass protection, which is exactly what the Bengals and Burrow need.
https://www.thedraftnetwork.com/2026/01/04/nfl-mock-draft-2026-january-5
Bleacher Report:
10. Edge David Bailey, Texas Tech
Instead of hoping Murphy and Stewart will develop into dynamic bookends, the Bengals can simply draft the 2026 class' most natural pass-rusher, David Bailey. "There aren't many, if any, pass-rushers in this year's draft class who have a deeper bag of moves that they can win with than Bailey," Holder said. "He does need some work against the run, but any team that has struggled putting pressure on opposing quarterbacks should be interested in the Texas Tech product."
https://bleacherreport.com/articles/25346393-br-nfl-scouting-depts-post-regular-season-2026-nfl-mock-draft
PFF:
10. DT KAYDEN McDONALD, OHIO STATE
Cincinnati finished dead last in the NFL in rushing yards allowed this season, surrendering nearly 150 yards per game on the ground. Adding Kayden McDonald would go a long way toward fixing that issue. The Ohio State interior defender earned a dominant 92.1 PFF run-defense grade and posted an elite 31.2% run-stop rate, giving the Bengals a true anchor in the middle of their defensive line. There’s a scenario where Cincinnati could trade down and still land McDonald, but with the board finalized and no trades in this mock, addressing their biggest weakness directly made the most sense.
https://www.pff.com/news/draft-post-week-18-mock-draft-raiders-fernando-mendoza-no-1-overall-commanders-caleb-downs