Who would you start

[combatbengal]

If you could pick any Bengal from the past or present, who would you have on the team?

QB:Palmer, Ken Anderson.

RB Paul Robinson, Rudi, and James Brooks.

WR: CJ, Cris Collinsworth, TJ, Eddie Brown

TE: Dan Ross, Rodney Holman

G: Max Montoya

NT: Tim Krumrie

s: David Fulcher

T: Munoz

K: Jim Breech

[Stripes]

QB - Anderson

RB - Dillon

WR - Brown, Johnson

TE - Ross

G - Montoya

T - Munoz

K - Breech

[andybren]

This is too hard.

[Wraith]

QB: Boomer Esiason

RB: Corey Dillon

FB: Lorenzo Neal

WR: Issac Curtis, Chad Johnson

TE: Dan Ross

G: Max Montoya, Dave Lapham

T: Willie Anderson, Anthony Munoz

C: Bob Johnson

DEs: Coy Bacon, Justin Smith

DT: Tim Krumrie, Mike Reid

LBs: Takeo Spikes, Brian Simmons, Reggie Williams

Ss: Daryl Williams, David Fulcher

CBs: Ashley Ambrose, Ken Riley

K: Jim Breech

P: Lee Johnson

[DC_Bengals_Fan]

QB: David Klingler

RB: Ki-jana Carter

FB: Larry Kinnebrew

TE: Bob Trumpy

C: Dave Remington

WRs: Carl Pickens, Peter Warrick

D-line: Alfred Williams, Dan Wilkinson

LBs: Reinard Wilson

CB: Ricky Dixon

[The_Next_Big_Thing]

QB: Carson Palmer

RB: Chris Perry

FB: Ickey Woods

TE: Dan Ross

C: Bruce Kozerski

G: Lapham and Montoya

T: Munoz and Anderson

WR: Chad Johnson and Chris Collinsworth

Dline: Tim Krumrie, Justin Smith, Robert Geathers

LBS: Takeo Smith, Brian Simmons, Mike Singletary (Ok, he never played for the Bengals, but this is a dream team right?)

CB: Ken Riley, Tory James

S: David Fulcher and Madieu Williams.

[Wraith]

Man, some of you need to Research Bengals history. Coy Bacon had an estimated 26 sacks one year but because sacks were "unofficial stats" he does not hold the record http://www.findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_..._111265554/pg_2. He, Ken Riley, an Mike Reid (who retired to become a concert pianist) are the first places you need to start when talking about All-Bengal defense. Frankly the best Bengals QB might have been Greg Cook who had one of the greatest rookie years in NFL history and then damaged his ACL which at the time was a career ending injury.

[The_Next_Big_Thing]

I debated a lot putting Justin Smith in over Coy Bacon, but the I think by the end of his career, Smith will have more tackles and sacks than Bacon. As for Geathers, maybe I'm crazy, but I think he will be in the HOF.

[jrandom42]

Frankly the best Bengals QB might have been Greg Cook who had one of the greatest rookie years in NFL history and then damaged his ACL which at the time was a career ending injury.

Actually, it was a shoulder injury, which was diagnosed much later as a torn rotator cuff.

Is it my imagination, or are there way too many similarities to Greg Cook and Carson Palmer?

[Stripes]

I see a lot of modern players on this list. How can Chris Perry be on anyone's list? C'mon now! 2 carries in his recorded career, and less than a 4 yard per carry average during the preseason.

[combatbengal]

Hey, that's not as bad as putting David Klingler in as QB. I noticed a lot of people picked Jim Breech and not shane o matic!

[Ox]

Well, how Boomer is not on your list I just don't know.

Also, Jim Breech still gets my nod for PK.