So as we wind down toward the official start of free agency at 4 pm today, how are we feeling about the results of the legal tampering period for the Bengals?
Overall, I'm good with what they've done. Not jumping out of my skin or anything, but far better than I expected to be, given this franchise's tendencies.
Bryan Cook was really high on my wish list. Geno Stone was easily the worst player on defense last season, and Cook is a high-end starter who might finally help us forget Jesse Bates.
Conversely, Boye Mafe was not on my radar. This is a similar signing to that of Hendrickson in 2021; Bengals are betting on the come again. I would be surprised if they caught lightning in a bottle twice in a row, but we'll see. Someone -- it might have been Goodberry -- comped him to Carl Lawson, which wouldn't be the worst result imaginable.
Like everyone else, I wanted to see some signings at DT and LB. But whether you're looking at FA or the draft, the DT options are all meh (which is why I've taken to pushing a trade).
At LB, here's the thing: they didn't spend 2nd and 4th rounders on LBs last year for those guys to play 8-10 snaps a game on teams. They drafted them to start and they started them both all last year, and anyone who expects that to change out of the gate in year two is, I think, fooling themselves. Did they look like two rooks completely out of their depth for much of 2025. Yup. Are they going to be expected to make big sophomore leaps in 2026? Also yup. If they don't, I would expect their PT to get cut, but I would guess they are going to get half a season to show if they've gotten better or not. As a second rounder, Knight probably gets the whole year barring some horrible regression.
All that is to say I don't think they were ever in the market for a guy like Lloyd or Chenal. They aren't looking for a guy to come in and start, they're looking for last year's rookies to step up. People, reasonable and otherwise, can disagree with that strategy. I'm not the biggest fan of it myself. But I think that's where they are at. What they are going to sign is one or two older, cheaper, experienced vets who shake loose (probably post-draft) and come in less for their play and more for their brains. Carter and Knight are physical enough, they just need to be in the right places to make plays, and that's what the vets will be there to do.
Anyhow, those are my probably wrong and completely stupid thoughts. Hope you enjoyed them.