What wr is the best

[bengalsfan4lifekf]

I say moss but i stil love chad, chad will be the best in a couple of years he is about to pass harrison

[Stripes]

Moss is having a better career through his first seven seasons than Jerry Rice did. He has to get the vote.

[NYBengalfan]

As much as i love chad I have to go with Holt because he does his job and does not say a word. In the near future....maybe a year or two 7-11(CJ) will rule the NFL

[The_Next_Big_Thing]

I go with Chad because while he talks smack, he works hard, and he doesn't hold out.

[mtmeece]

Could anyone see what looked like disgust on Moss's face durring his first game as a Raider.

[ShulaSteakhouse]

Moss is an unlikeable jerk-off like Owens but those two are #'s 1 and 2 respectively IMO. Harrison has lost a step, but for a few years there he was the best in my mind during the late 90's and up til about 2002 or so.

CJ probably fits in somewhere in the top 5, just not sure where. Still waiting for Chad to put some meat on his bones and become more of a complete receiver, even Moss has bulked up over time a bit.

I think Chad would benefit greatly from having the leverage Owens does so he doesn't have to solely rely on quickness to get open or out of the blocks when he's bumped.

Word to Chad - quit talkin' and eating McDonald's crap and start drinking protein shakes and adding lean muscle. When he does he'll be unstoppable like those 2.

[AGrizzlyBaer]

i said harrison you get all the greatness as well as the lack of crazyness thats just me though

[staticx682000]

Moss hands down and whats scary is he takes plays off....I prob would have went with chad but he has no yac.......

[7/11]

randy moss, with t.o. a close second...if you said chad, you're only a homer. when chad gets more YAC, he might be top-3, but he's still behind moss, t.o., harrison, holt and javon walker in my opinion.

[DesperateDerelict]

Do we factor in attitude and locker room presence. If not, it's Moss Man. If so, it's a tie between CJ & Holt.

[buck3y3d]

I go with Chad because while he talks smack, he works hard, and he doesn't hold out.

I think Chad could very easily hold out. Everything i hear is that next year Chad will probably hold out.

Evidence:

Sympathizes with TO (says he is underpaid, hard to believe 49 mil isn't enough)

Has an agent (Rosenhause) were holding out is the norm

He said he hasn't ruled out a hold out for next year

These are all what ifs, but it would not suprise me at all to see Chad hold out.

[semiotter]

I say there is to many good WRs in this leauge to pick one saying he is the best. Its like all the sport call in shows saying when Jerry Rice ret., who was the greatest Football player ever?? There is no answer...

[Kirkendall]

Harrison for me. Class still goes a long way (as in WR that will stay on same team, not bitch about contract, yada yada yada -- the greats play through the pains of rebuilding too and in that it redefines them)

[bengalfreek]

If you're going by where they are at the same stage of their careers, the answer is Randy Moss. But if you're going by who is better now, T.O. hands down.

[John Stofa]

I'm assuming we're talking about WR skills only, so I picked Randy Moss.

[John Stofa]

Harrison for me. Class still goes a long way (as in WR that will stay on same team, not bitch about contract, yada yada yada -- the greats play through the pains of rebuilding too and in that it redefines them)

If class is one of the voting criteria then a couple of those guys shouldn't be on the list.

[OrangeStripes]

I say moss but i stil love chad

Yea i would probably go with chad

[Jet23]

Moss and Owens are 1 & 1A. Everyone else is playing for 2nd. I love Harrison's attitude, but imagine what Moss and Owens could do with Peyton chucking it their way. Harrison, Holt, Chad, Muhammad, S. Smith are all in the 2nd group.

[jditty47]

top 5 by impact:

TO

Moss

CJ

Harrison

Holt

Top 5 by pure skill:

TO

CJ

Harrison

Holt

Moss

[Who?]

Moss without a doubt, since he has been in this league he has been nothing but dominant, recording like 17 touchdowns in his rookie year or something like that.

[bengalboomer7]

Here's my argument of why randy Moss is not the best WR in the NFL. And just to make sure, we are talking about "recievers" right. Moss just goes deep, he's the best at it, but that's all. Can't or Won't go over the middle, short or long. So, if we're talking "reciever" then I could make an argument for T.O, Harrison, and Holt, but not Chad.....yet.

[odellthurmanfan]

Much as I hate to admit it, TO followed by Moss and Holt. Harrison and Chad are on the same level I think, below the top 3.