Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

I haven`t seen a clip of the pass incompletion... errr TD catch.

Except for the highlight video on bengals.com.

http://www.bengals.com/media/index.asp?multimedia_id=1060

Here is a clip on the sack...errr roughing penalty on Justin.

The TD catch is debatable. Although the call was incomplete pass,

so I`m not sure if there was enough evidence to over ride the call

on the field. But the penalty on Justin was just horrible... inexcusable, BS.

Posted

There were four controversial calls in my mind:

1) Tory's interception - overturned

2) TJ's touchdown - stands

3) Justin's roughing the passer - non-reviewable

4) TD at the end - overturned

The one no one's been mentioning was Tory's interception. I know it happened earlier, but that could have been big too. I was watching on a small TV in a bar, but I couldn't see a shot that clearly showed a patch of grass where the ball hit - looked like he had his hands under it. Anyone have some better intel on that one?

For what it's worth, he did score at the end. As for the roughing the passer call, Marvin's quote was the best ever from him.

Posted

I thought Tory's interception was obvious too, as in it wasn't a pick. The ball hit the ground as he was rolling over it (with both his hands nowhere in sight), and that caused it to bounce back up where he could get it again.

Posted
The call on Smith was bad, but as I saw it... the touchdown was obvious. He scored.

Must agree. He got in the endzone before the ball came out. The problem is, they never should have had that chance in the first place. If there's no BS roughing the passer call, then that was a fumble recovery by Geathers I believe, and the game is over. Total BS...although I agree that they should have played better so this wasn't even a possibility.

I think the other awful call was on the Bucs first TD drive when Geathers was called for roughing the passer which gave them a 1st down in the red zone instead of a second and long.

Awful ref'ing all day. It makes me sick.

Posted
I thought Tory's interception was obvious too, as in it wasn't a pick. The ball hit the ground as he was rolling over it (with both his hands nowhere in sight), and that caused it to bounce back up where he could get it again.

I blame the 19" TV and beer. Thanks.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...