Best Rookie.

[ChadJohnson-85]

IMO Ahmad Brooks, Reggie McNeal or Johnathan Joseph.

And for the second Question, well I hope so.

[aaronburr]

Is this based on performance so far? Or anticipated performance during the rest of their careers? 'Cause I haven't heard Reggie McNeal's name in any of the coverage of training camp. In fact, most of these guys are barely getting mentioned.

[ChadJohnson-85]

Is this based on performance so far? Or anticipated performance during the rest of their careers?

During the regular season as a rookie.

[Kazkal]

Will the Bengals keep Odell?

wow you do lose at polls

[ChadJohnson-85]

Will the Bengals keep Odell?

wow you do lose at polls

There has been surprise cuts before. Especially if they've gotten in trouble.

[derekshank]

Ethan Kilmer will be a stud on special teams from day one. If we are talking about the biggest impact THIS year from start to finish, I have to go with him. I don't see anyone else on that list that will start the first few games.

A few weeks ago I might have said Joseph... but it's looking like he's got a lot of competition to beat out to even be the Nickle right now.

[The_Next_Big_Thing]

Biggest impact player WILL be Joseph, but not because he's on the field. The Joseph pick spurs Ratliff on, turning him into the stud corner we though we had drafted when we picked him. Ratliff and Joseph turn into a one two punch for years to come.

[TJJackson]

DE Eric Henderson

[Kazkal]

DE Eric Henderson

JJ should be a stud combine wise hes faster then Dhall

[WretchedOne]

I agree with TJ.

[ChadJohnson-85]

DE Eric Henderson

Crap I Forgot Henderson.

[BlueResident]

From what I've heard so far from camp, I'm most excited about Brooks...can' wait to see him play

As for immediate impact, I dunno...we have some pretty talented rookies

[ChadJohnson-85]

From what I've heard so far from camp, I'm most excited about Brooks...can' wait to see him play

As for immediate impact, I dunno...we have some pretty talented rookies

Can you imagine Simmons, Brooks, Thurman & Pollack in a 3-4. All we really need to do is get our d-line straightened out & we'll be set. Brooks is gonna be a great player for us & in the future we'll have the best LineBacker corp in the NFL.

Who Dey!!!

[Kazkal]

I like the idea of fanene-peko-high pick DE next year as front 3 for 3-4

[Spain]

peko, ditto to what kazkal said.

[derekshank]

WOOHOO! Someone else voted for Kilmer. There is another person out there that shares my madness!