Geno Atkins 4-Year Extension! And now Dunlap Too !! in Cincinnati Bengals Posted August 28, 2018 · Report reply 33 minutes ago, Stripes said: I know it’s ultimately a meaningless discussion, but I’d be curious to know where y’all would rank Geno all-time among Bengals defensive players. #1 and that will be borne out when he becomes the Bengals second player to become a first ballot hall of famer.